Laces vs. Velcro: The Great Children’s Shoe Debate

As a single dad and a schoolteacher with a deep understanding of child development, I’ve had my fair share of experiences with kiddos and their shoes. The choice between laces and Velcro might seem trivial, but it can impact your child’s comfort, independence, and even their school experience. Let’s dive into this important debate, considering age considerations, child development, school requirements, and more.

Age Considerations


Pros: Laces provide a snug fit, which is essential for ankle support, making them a better choice for older kiddos (around 6 years and up).

Cons: Younger kiddos might struggle with laces due to fine motor skill development. Tying laces can be frustrating and time-consuming for them.


Pros: Velcro straps are a breeze for younger kiddos (around 3-5 years) to fasten independently. No more waiting for help!

Cons: Velcro might not provide the same level of support as laces, so it’s essential to consider the type of activities your kiddos engage in.

Child Development


Pros: Learning to tie shoelaces is a valuable developmental milestone. It enhances fine motor skills and hand-eye coordination.

Cons: Kiddos need patience and practice to master laces, which can be frustrating at times.


Pros: Velcro fosters independence and self-confidence in younger children. They can put on and take off their shoes with ease.

Cons: Some argue that relying on Velcro might delay fine motor skill development for activities like writing.

School Requirements


Pros: Some schools prefer laces for uniformity and neatness. Older kiddos are generally expected to manage laces independently.

Cons: Younger kids might struggle with laces during school activities and physical education.


Pros: Velcro is incredibly convenient for daycare and preschool settings, where teachers appreciate the ease of helping multiple children with their shoes.

Cons: As children get older, Velcro might not meet school requirements, potentially causing issues with dress codes.

Practical Considerations


Pros: Once mastered, laces can provide a more secure fit, making them suitable for activities like sports or running.

Cons: They require occasional retying, which can be inconvenient during playtime.


Pros: Quick and hassle-free, making them ideal for daily wear and activities where shoes need to be put on and taken off frequently.

Cons: Over time, Velcro may wear out and lose its grip, leading to the need for replacement.

The Verdict

The choice between laces and Velcro isn’t a one-size-fits-all decision. It depends on your child’s age, their developmental stage, and school requirements. For younger kiddos, Velcro provides convenience and independence. As they grow and develop fine motor skills, transitioning to laces can be a valuable skill-building exercise.

Ultimately, it’s essential to strike a balance. Encourage your child to learn to tie laces as they get older, but don’t rush the process. Let them enjoy the convenience of Velcro when they’re young, and when the time is right, introduce them to the world of laces. This way, they’ll have the best of both worlds – convenience and skill.

In my experience as a single dad and schoolteacher, what matters most is the comfort and confidence of your kiddo. Whichever shoe fastening method you choose, ensure it suits your child’s needs and supports their development. After all, the goal is for your kiddos to put on their shoes with a smile on their face, ready to take on the adventures of the day.


Leave a Comment

Shopping Cart